A marriage of thirteen months to an oilman with a large holding in Koch Industries took Anna Nicole Smith’s claim to the Supreme Court twice, won findings against her stepson in two federal courts, lost before a Texas jury, and ended with no award left standing.
The usual version has Anna Nicole Smith beating the Marshall family at the Supreme Court. She did, once, in May 2006, on the question of which courts were allowed to hear her. Five years later the same court ruled 5–4 against her estate, and the federal damages award that had made the dispute famous did not survive the judgment.
Between those two rulings, two federal courts in California found against the son and a Texas jury found for him. The Supreme Court, on its second visit, decided who had been entitled to the last word. The figures given here are the ones the courts wrote into their opinions, including the cents where a judge chose to include them.
By our count nineteen years passed between Marshall’s death on 4 August 1995 and the last federal ruling, on 18 August 2014. The marriage that began it lasted thirteen months.
Marshall was an oilman with a stake in Koch
J. Howard Marshall II, in the Ninth Circuit’s account, was one of the founders of the Great Northern Oil and Gas Company in 1954 and by 1995 held 14.7 per cent of Koch Industries through entities he controlled. He married Smith on 27 June 1994. The courts used her legal name, Vickie Lynn Marshall. He died on 4 August 1995, aged ninety.
His younger son, E. Pierce Marshall, became the other party in the federal cases that followed.
Readers who come looking for one figure for the Marshall fortune get an estimate: the Associated Press put the estate at $1.6 billion in 2014. Koch Industries is privately held. The money in this case is the money judges put a price on, and that is a different and more precise sum. The courts were not asked what the oilman was worth. They were asked what one person had lost and who had caused the loss.
Her fight began in her own bankruptcy
After Marshall’s death, Vickie filed for bankruptcy in the Central District of California. That filing is how a Texas inheritance dispute ended up in a federal courtroom in California. Pierce Marshall filed a claim in her bankruptcy, for defamation. She objected to it and filed a counterclaim of her own: that he had tortiously interfered with a gift she expected from his father.
The bankruptcy court held that both her objection and her counterclaim were “core proceedings” under the federal bankruptcy statute. That meant it could enter final judgment on them itself, without passing the decision up to a district judge.
DDW’s reading is that this was the hinge of the whole case. The last ruling in Washington came back to whether a bankruptcy judge had been entitled to sign that judgment.
A bankruptcy judge found Pierce Marshall liable
The bankruptcy court found against Pierce Marshall, relying in part on findings it had imposed on him as sanctions for discovery abuses. Its revised judgment of 6 October 2000 was entered against him personally for $449,754,134, less whatever proceeds Vickie received from J. Howard Marshall II’s estate, as the Ninth Circuit later recorded it. The judgment entered on 29 December 2000 added punitive damages of $25 million.
The clause after the number matters most. The compensatory award was written net of whatever the estate itself would pay her, so a federal judge in California was valuing a loss whose other half was being decided somewhere else.
DDW’s reading is that the clause tells you how the federal case was built. The Supreme Court would later describe her claims as an attempt to secure half of J. Howard’s fortune; the judgment itself was entered against the son in his individual capacity, not against the estate.
A district judge kept the finding, cut the damages
In 2001 the district court agreed with the bankruptcy court that the federal courts had jurisdiction over the tortious-interference claim. It disagreed on the more technical point and reversed the finding that the claim was “core”.
Having reversed that finding, the district court treated the bankruptcy judgment as a proposal rather than a final decision, and reviewed the record itself. It reached the same conclusion on liability. Like the bankruptcy court, it found that Pierce had tortiously interfered with Vickie’s expectancy of a gift. It then set the damages itself, awarding compensatory and punitive damages, each of $44,292,767.33, plus the costs of the suit.
The finding survived the review, but most of the money did not.
At this stage two federal courts had found the same man liable, and a Texas court had found the opposite. The Texas probate court held a five-month jury trial in which Vickie took full part; on 7 March 2001 the jury found the will and the living trust valid and found no fraud or undue influence, and the court entered judgment for Pierce Marshall. The district court declined to treat that judgment as binding. In the Ninth Circuit’s 2010 summary, both the bankruptcy and the district courts had found Pierce Marshall liable for tortious interference. The same opinion held that the Texas findings were the earliest final judgment and should have controlled.
Ginsburg wrote the Supreme Court’s first ruling
Pierce Marshall’s first serious success came in 2004, at the Ninth Circuit, on grounds that had nothing to do with the facts. The appeals court held that the probate exception, a judge-made limit on federal courts’ power over estates, barred federal jurisdiction altogether. On that view the award should never have been made.
The Supreme Court took the case as Marshall v. Marshall, with Vickie Lynn Marshall as petitioner and Pierce Marshall as respondent. It heard argument on 28 February 2006 and decided the case on 1 May 2006. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote for the Court. She held that the Ninth Circuit had “no warrant from Congress”, nor anything in the Court’s own decisions, for what she called its sweeping extension of the probate exception. Justice Stevens filed an opinion concurring in part and concurring in the judgment.
The Court reversed the Ninth Circuit and sent the case back. The Ninth Circuit was to consider the questions it had not reached: whether Vickie’s counterclaim really was “core”, and Pierce’s arguments that earlier rulings already barred the claim and the issues it raised. This was the win that made the headlines, and it was a win on procedure. The Court decided that the federal courts could hear her case. It said nothing about whether she should succeed.
Roberts’s majority ruled against her estate
The Ninth Circuit ruled again in 2010, and the case returned to Washington as Stern v. Marshall. By then the parties were estates. Hers was represented by Howard K. Stern as executor, and Pierce Marshall’s by Elaine Marshall as executrix. The Court agreed to hear the case on 28 September 2010 and heard argument on 18 January 2011.
The question before the Court was a narrow one. A bankruptcy judge does not have the life tenure and salary protection that Article III of the Constitution gives federal judges. Could such a judge enter final judgment on Vickie’s counterclaim? The Court’s answer had two parts. It held that the statute, 28 USC §157(b), did authorise the bankruptcy court to enter that judgment. It also held that Article III did not permit it. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote that the bankruptcy court “lacked the constitutional authority to do so.”
The vote was 5–4, decided on 23 June 2011. Justices Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas and Alito joined the Chief Justice. Justice Breyer dissented, joined by Justices Ginsburg, Sotomayor and Kagan. The justice who wrote Smith’s 2006 victory therefore signed the dissent in her estate’s 2011 defeat.
DDW’s reading is that her side won the argument about the statute and lost the argument about the Constitution, and the constitutional argument decided the case. The Supreme Court affirmed the Ninth Circuit, so the federal damages award did not stand. Rehearing was denied, and the Court issued its judgment on 15 August 2011.
Texas probate ran alongside the federal case
Did Anna Nicole Smith ever get any of the Marshall money? The federal answer is clear. None of the awards survived Stern: not the bankruptcy court’s nine-figure judgment and not the district court’s reduced one. In Texas the jury had found for Pierce Marshall. What she kept were the gifts of the courtship and marriage, which the Ninth Circuit says he lavished on her along with significant sums of money.
The US Solicitor General’s amicus brief in the 2006 case described the bankruptcy award as compensatory damages “less whatever she recovered in the ongoing probate action in Texas”, with punitive damages on top. The bankruptcy court’s own revised judgment used similar wording. The federal case was always about what she had lost, measured after the Texas estate had paid her whatever it was going to pay.
It ended three years later. On 18 August 2014 Judge David O. Carter, in the federal court in Orange County, refused her estate’s request for about $44 million in sanctions against Pierce Marshall’s estate, the Associated Press reported, and called it the last surviving piece of the litigation. He closed with the Supreme Court’s own borrowing from Bleak House: it was time for the suit to no longer “drag its weary length before the Court”.
Read Next: 5 Rungs of the Kardashian-Jenner Net Worth Ladder in 2026











