A magazine of the heirs, houses and rituals of modern wealth

Widow of Campbell Soup's former chairman
Taste & Travel•3 Minutes Read

Betsy Sherman Asks Miami Beach for a Zuckerberg Price

November 21, 2026•Share

A Campbell’s chairman’s widow has priced her Miami Beach house at exactly what Mark Zuckerberg paid for his across the water in March, which gives Miami one number, two islands and two houses with nothing else in common.

Miami has turned up in the same dress twice this year. In March it was Mark Zuckerberg wearing it. In November it is Betsy Sherman, whose house on La Gorce Island in Miami Beach came onto the market on 13 November at $170m, The Real Deal reported on 18 November. That is the same sum a limited liability company paid on 2 March for 7 Indian Creek Island Road, the estate that Homes.com names as bought by Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan.

The two stories have been running side by side, so it helps to be plain about it. These are two separate houses on two separate islands, built by different people and in the news eight months apart. One is a closed sale; the other is an asking price, which is a hope with an agent.

Indian Creek bought its house unfinished

The Zuckerberg house was still under construction when it sold, according to Homes.com: a residence of 27,889 square feet on Indian Creek Island Road, in the tiny municipality of Indian Creek Village. The buyer of record is a limited liability company. Zuckerberg’s and Chan’s names reach the house through reporting rather than through the deed, and they belong in the sentence on that basis only.

What the couple bought, then, was a house someone else had planned and not yet finished. That is a particular kind of luxury: the work is done by the previous owner, and the decisions are left to the new one.

A chairman finished his on La Gorce

The Sherman house is the opposite case. George M. Sherman and his wife bought the 1.2-acre property in 2006 for $17m, property records show, and the house was completed in 2015. The listing went public this month, though it had been available off-market over the summer.

The Sherman biography at UMBC records a career spent running other people’s companies: executive vice president at Black & Decker, then president and chief executive of Danaher, then chairman of Campbell’s from 2001 to 2004, followed by chairing Rexnord and Encapsys and founding his own firm, Cypress Group, before his death in 2021.

His was a career at the very top of American management. In its own circles, that counts as a pedigree.

The Campbell heiress has her own listing

The same report from The Real Deal carries a second Campbell’s house, and it has a stronger claim to the soup itself. An entity tied to the late Mary Alice Malone, a Campbell’s heiress, is asking $112m for a 100-acre equestrian farm in Wellington.

By our count, that report lists two Florida properties linked to Campbell’s: the Shermans’ house on La Gorce and the Malone farm at Wellington. Only the second comes from the family’s own fortune. The Shermans’ connection came through the boardroom, by appointment.

Soup money, in other words, is a phrase to use with a ladle and some care.

Betsy Sherman is going back to Fisher Island

What she has said is brief. Betsy Sherman was reluctant to list the house, she has said, but she felt it was time for another family to enjoy it. She plans to move back to Fisher Island, where she lived before La Gorce. That will do as a reason.

Jill Hertzberg of the Jills Zeder Group holds the listing, and a price has been set. The rest belongs to whichever buyer decides that a finished house on La Gorce is worth what Zuckerberg paid for an unfinished one on Indian Creek.

Same dress, then, though only one of them came finished.


Read Next: Warren Beatty’s Old House Now Has His Name on It

Author:Marianne Shaw

Email this story to a friend

· For several friends (up to 20), put a comma between the addresses. We keep none of them.

Get Don’t Die Wondering by email

Now and then, the best of the magazine. No spam; leave whenever you like. Privacy